Save what you pay for payroll, free
Create your free account, write down what you pay today for payroll and your other services, and see your total spend and which options could cost you less with your numbers.
Nobody calls or messages you unless you ask.
Free. Nobody calls or messages you unless you ask. How we make money
Save it freeRTC SCORE
7.0
#5 of 22 with enough data
Homebase Payroll
Payroll added to Homebase's scheduling and time clock app, at $49 a month plus $6 per employee paid. It files federal, state and local taxes, and imports tips from Toast, Square and Clover through its Tip Manager.
RTC SCORE
7.4
#2 of 22 with enough data
Square Payroll
Square's payroll, billed monthly plus a fee per person paid. It files federal, state and supported local taxes, pays its own filing errors, and imports tips from Square's POS.
Key differences
| Data point | Homebase Payroll | Square Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Base fee | $49/mo | $35/mo |
| Live support hours a week | 84 | 60 |
Side by side
| Feature | Homebase PayrollRTC Score: 7.0 out of 10 | Square PayrollRTC Score: 7.4 out of 10 |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | ||
| Base fee | $49/moSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Plus a team plan per location: Basic is $0 for one location with up to 10 employees; Essentials $30, Plus $70 and All-in-One $120. | $35/mo(Best value)Source: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Per employee | $6Source: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | $6Source: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Who counts as an employee | Each person paid that monthSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | Each person paid that monthSource: Square (opens in a new tab)You pay per person paid; seasonal inactivity is free. |
| Per contractor (1099) | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase doesn't say whether a contractor paid through payroll counts toward the $6 per employee paid. | $6Source: Square (opens in a new tab)There is also a contractor-only plan at $6 per person paid. |
| Published pricing | PublishedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | PublishedSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Setup fee | $0 one-timeSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | $0 one-timeSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Square's pricing page lists only the monthly fee, the fee per person paid and the optional paper forms; it shows no setup charge. |
| Year-end forms fee | $0/yrSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)W-2s and 1099s are generated and delivered digitally within that price; Homebase publishes no year-end charge. | $0/yrSource: Square (opens in a new tab)W-2 and 1099 forms are filed and delivered digitally at no charge. Paper copies mailed by Square cost $3 per employee or contractor a year, only if you opt in. |
| Each extra state | $0Source: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | $0Source: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Each state or tax jurisdiction where you run payroll is filed at no additional charge. |
| Other fees | Next Day Pay costs $49 a month plus $9 per person instead of the standard payroll price. Tip Manager: $25 per location a month. Instant Cash Out for employees has a fee that the employee pays.Source: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | Paper W-2 and 1099 copies mailed by Square: $3 per employee or contractor a year (optional). Employees who take their pay early to a debit card or bank account pay 1.75%; to Cash App it's free.Source: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Taxes and forms | ||
| Who files payroll taxes | The provider calculates, files and pays federal, state and local payroll taxesSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | The provider calculates, files and pays federal, state and local payroll taxesSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Square files supported local taxes (for example New York City, Yonkers, Ohio and Pennsylvania local agencies, Kansas City and St. Louis). If a local tax isn't supported, you file it and Square gives you a quarterly wage report. |
| Payroll in all 50 states | YesSource: Homebase Help Center (opens in a new tab)Homebase's payroll FAQ says payroll is available in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. The help center page asks for a human verification step; we read its text in the search index and did not get around the check. | YesSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab) |
| Year-end W-2 and 1099 forms | W-2 and 1099 prepared and filedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | W-2 and 1099 prepared and filedSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Forms it files: 941, 940, 944, 1099-NEC, W-2 and W-3. |
| Paying 1099 contractors | Included in payroll plansSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | Also a contractor-only planSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Tax penalty guarantee | No guarantee publishedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)We found no published guarantee to pay penalties caused by Homebase's errors on its payroll, tax or pricing pages. | Pays penalties caused by its own errorsSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab) |
| Garnishments and new-hire reporting | IncludedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Child support is sent to the agency for you; other garnishments (tax levies, student loans, consumer debt) are withheld and you remit them. New-hire reports are filed. | IncludedSource: Square (opens in a new tab)New-hire reports are filed for you. Garnishments are withheld from pay, but you send the money to the agency yourself. |
| Paying your team | ||
| Pay schedules | Weekly, Every two weeks, Twice a month, MonthlySource: Homebase Help Center (opens in a new tab)Weekly, every two weeks, twice a month or monthly. The help center page asks for a human verification step; we read its text in the search index and did not get around the check. | Weekly, Every two weeks, Twice a month, MonthlySource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab) |
| Unlimited pay runs | YesSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | YesSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Fastest direct deposit included | Three or more business daysSource: Homebase Help Center (opens in a new tab)New accounts start on 3-business-day processing and move to 2 days after 10 successful payrolls. Next-day deposits cost extra ($49 a month plus $9 per person). The help center page asks for a human verification step; we read its text in the search index and did not get around the check. | Next daySource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Next business day when you fund payroll from your Square balance. Funded from another bank account, deposits take four business days, or two with two-day payroll, which you apply for. |
| Early pay for employees (earned wage access) | Included at no cost to the employerSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Standard Cash Out is free for the employee; instant Cash Out has a fee the employee pays. | Included at no cost to the employerSource: Square (opens in a new tab)On Demand Pay and Instant Deposit: free for employees to Cash App; 1.75% to a debit card or bank account. Instant Deposit isn't available in CA, MA, NJ, NM, NY, PA, VT and WV. |
| Tips | ||
| Imports tips from these POS systems | Clover, Square, ToastSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | SquareSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Card and cash tips from Square POS, pooled or direct. It leaves out auto-gratuities and contractors' tips. |
| Tip pooling and tip-outs | Paid add-on or higher planSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Tip Manager, $25 per location a month; it pools tips by hours. | Paid add-on or higher planSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)With Square Shifts Plus or the Plus and Premium plans. |
| Tip credit and minimum wage make-up | Claimed, without documented mechanicsSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase says federal, state and local minimums apply with no manual adjustments, without documenting how. | UnconfirmedSource: Square Seller Community (opens in a new tab)Not documented. In 2022 a Square moderator filed automatic tip credit make-up as a feature request; we found no newer Square page that describes it. |
| FICA tip credit (Form 8846) | Not supportedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase keeps the data and sends you to your tax adviser for Form 8846. | Not supportedSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Form 8846 isn't among the forms Square files. |
| Declared cash tips | YesSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | YesSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)"Tips Already Paid" and "Paycheck Tips" fields. |
| 2026 W-2 for No Tax on Tips (code TP and tipped occupation code) | Not confirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)We found no Homebase page that confirms code TP or the tipped occupation code on the 2026 W-2. | Not confirmedSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Square's W-2 article and its No Tax on Tips post (2025 amounts on pay stubs) don't confirm code TP or the tipped occupation code on the 2026 W-2. |
| 2026 W-2 for qualified overtime (code TT) | Not confirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)We found no Homebase page that confirms code TT on the 2026 W-2. | Not confirmedSource: Square Seller Community (Square staff post) (opens in a new tab)Square's post covers how employees find 2025 amounts on their pay stubs; it doesn't confirm codes TT or TP on the 2026 W-2. |
| Service charges paid as wages | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase doesn't document how its payroll treats mandatory service charges. | NoSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Square's tip import does not support auto-gratuity from Square for Restaurants; you add service charges to the pay run yourself. |
| State and local minimum wages built in | YesSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Marketing claim; Homebase doesn't publish how it keeps the rates current. | UnconfirmedSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Not documented on Square's payroll pages or help articles we read. |
| Integrations and time tracking | ||
| POS integrations (hours or sales data) | Toast, Square, Clover, Lightspeed, PAR, OthersSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Others: GoDaddy and Shopify. | SquareSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Time tracking | IncludedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)The free Basic plan covers one location with up to 10 employees; above that, the team plan (Essentials or higher) is required and is included in the cost. | IncludedSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Timecards come from Square POS or the Square Team app (free Square Shifts). |
| Scheduling | IncludedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | IncludedSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Accounting integrations | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase's QuickBooks integration syncs employees and hours into QuickBooks Online Plus (for running payroll there); it doesn't document posting Homebase Payroll to an accounting system. | QuickBooks OnlineSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab) |
| Payroll engine | Check (a payroll infrastructure provider)Source: Check Technologies (opens in a new tab) | The vendor itselfSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab) |
| Benefits and insurance | ||
| Health benefits | Through a partner brokerSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Health, dental and vision options for teams under 50 through integrated partners. | Through a partner brokerSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Workers' compensation | Pay-as-you-go connected to payrollSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | Pay-as-you-go connected to payrollSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Pay-as-you-go workers' comp through Square's partner, with premiums based on each payroll run. |
| Contract and exit | ||
| Initial term | Month to monthSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Month to month. | Month to monthSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Month to month: Square says there is no long-term commitment. |
| Automatic renewal | Month to monthSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Billed month to month. | Month to monthSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Billed month to month. |
| Notice to avoid renewal | 0 daysSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | 0 daysSource: Square (opens in a new tab)You cancel from your Square account settings; access continues to the end of the billing period, with no refund. |
| Early termination fee | NoneSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Month to month: no term and no early termination fee. | NoneSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Month to month: no term and no early termination fee. |
| Early termination clause | No early termination fee.Source: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | No early termination fee.Source: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Right to raise prices | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase's terms of service didn't load for us (the page needs JavaScript); we couldn't read its price-change clause. | Square can change subscription fees with reasonable advance notice; using the service after the notice means you accept the change.Source: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Free trial or free months | 180 daysSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Limited-time offer for new customers: 6 months of payroll and the Plus plan free, if payroll setup is done by Dec 15, 2026 and the first payroll runs by Jan 20, 2027. | UnconfirmedSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Square's payroll pricing page shows no free trial or free months today. |
| Your records when you leave | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase doesn't publish how long you keep access to payroll records after you cancel. | UnconfirmedSource: Square Support Center (opens in a new tab)Square's help center says closing the payroll account is irreversible; it doesn't say how long you keep access to reports afterwards. |
| Support | ||
| Support 24/7 | NoSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Around the clock it's an AI chat; live people answer 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Central. | NoSource: Square (opens in a new tab) |
| Live support hours a week | 84(Best value)Source: Homebase (opens in a new tab)12 hours a day, every day, per the payroll page and the help center (Mon to Sun). An older comparison table on Homebase's site says 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., Monday to Friday. | 60Source: Square (opens in a new tab)12 hours a day, Monday to Friday. |
| Dedicated specialist | YesSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | YesSource: Square (opens in a new tab)Square describes dedicated payroll specialists for setup and questions; it doesn't say each account gets one assigned person. |
Contracts compared
| Product | Initial term | Auto-renewal | Early termination fee | Price increases during the term | Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homebase PayrollSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab) | Month to month | No auto-renewal | No early termination fee. | UnconfirmedSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Homebase's terms of service didn't load for us (the page needs JavaScript); we couldn't read its price-change clause. | 180-day trialSource: Homebase (opens in a new tab)Limited-time offer for new customers: 6 months of payroll and the Plus plan free, if payroll setup is done by Dec 15, 2026 and the first payroll runs by Jan 20, 2027. |
| Square PayrollSource: Square (opens in a new tab) | Month to month | No auto-renewal | No early termination fee. | Square can change subscription fees with reasonable advance notice; using the service after the notice means you accept the change.Source: Square (opens in a new tab) | Unconfirmed |
This is general information about published contracts, not legal advice: read your own contract and check with a lawyer before you sign.
Build your own comparisonPayroll cost calculatorHow we score