Skip to content

Loyalty, CRM & gift cards

Restaurant loyalty, CRM and gift card software, compared

Every loyalty and gift card platform here is scored with the same public rubric. Each number links to its source and shows when we last verified it.

17 loyalty and gift card platforms · Updated Oct 17, 2026Public methodology · updated Oct 17, 2026

We keep verifying each platform's data against its own pages, so some cells read "Unconfirmed" or "Not published" until we check them.

Loyalty software covers three different purchases: rewarding guests who come back, keeping a guest list you can reach with campaigns, and selling gift cards. Some platforms do all three; others do one well. The table shows what each one costs for one location, including text messages, how guests earn rewards, which campaigns you can send, whether it sells gift cards, which POS systems it works with and what happens to your guest list if you leave. If a platform doesn't publish its price, you'll see "Not published" or "Quote only", never a zero.

Before you pick one, three questions save money:

  • Does it work with the POS you already have? A program built into your POS is easy to run, but your guest list stays there if you switch systems. A platform that connects to several POS systems moves with you.
  • What do text messages really cost? Many plans include an allowance and charge for each message beyond it. Count how many guests you'll text and how often.
  • Will it bring guests who wouldn't have come anyway? A reward on a visit that was going to happen is a discount, not new sales. Compare guests in the program with similar guests outside it before you call it a win.

Gift-card-only platforms are listed with the same template and no score, because they aren't a loyalty program.

Highest RTC Scores

Ranked by RTC Score with our default weights. Rankings by type of business are below.

  1. RTC SCORE

    8.3

    #1 overall

    Square Loyalty

    Square's points, visits or items loyalty program, built into Square's POS and included in the Square Plus plan along with email and text campaigns, a customer directory and gift cards.

    Read the review
  2. RTC SCORE

    7.1

    #2 overall

    SpotOn Loyalty

    SpotOn's points-or-visits loyalty program, sold as an add-on to SpotOn's restaurant POS. Guests earn and redeem in the restaurant, on its online ordering and in the GoTo Place app, and every sign-up feeds SpotOn's email and text campaigns.

    Read the review
  3. RTC SCORE

    7.1

    #3 overall

    TapMango

    A loyalty and marketing platform for counter-service businesses such as coffee shops, quick-service and fast-casual restaurants, with a customer-facing tablet at the register, text and email campaigns, online ordering and an app with your brand. It connects to Toast, Square, Clover and many other POS systems, or runs on its own tablet.

    Read the review

See the full ranking

All loyalty and gift card platforms

Showing all 17 products

Check 2 to 4 products to compare them side by side.

17 loyalty and gift card platforms; loyalty programs ranked by RTC ScoreScroll sideways to see every column.
ProductRTC ScoreInitial termEarly terminationMonthly price
#1Square LoyaltySquare
8.3out of 10Month to monthThe terms set no early termination fee$49/mo
#2SpotOn LoyaltySpotOn
7.1out of 1024 months100% of the fees left in the term$65/mo
#3TapMangoTapMango
7.1out of 10Quote onlyQuote onlyQuote only
#4LoyalzooLoyalzoo
7.0out of 10Month to monthThe terms set no early termination fee$77/mo
#5IncentivioIncentivio
6.8out of 1012 monthsNo exit for convenience: an order can only be ended early for a breach not fixed within 30 days. Fees already accrued are still owed.Quote only
#6Clover RewardsClover
6.6out of 10Quote onlyQuote only$29.95/mo
#7Toast LoyaltyToast
6.4out of 10Quote only100% of the fees left in the termQuote only
#8PaytronixPaytronix
6.3out of 10Quote onlyQuote onlyQuote only
#9PAR PunchhPAR Technology
5.9out of 10Quote onlyNo exit for convenience: you can end it early only if PAR materially breaches and doesn't fix it within 30 days, or goes insolvent. Fees are non-refundable, and open subscriptions run to the end of their term.Quote only
#10PopmenuPopmenu
5.6out of 10Quote only100% of the fees left in the term$179/mo
#11SumUp ConnectSumUp
5.2out of 10Quote onlyQuote only$199/mo
#12ThanxThanx
4.9out of 10Quote onlyNo exit for convenience before the term ends: you can only end it early for an uncured breach. Fees are non-refundable and can't be lowered for any location during the term.Quote only
#13Olo Loyalty (Spendgo)Olo
4.8out of 10Quote only100% of the fees left in the termQuote only
Gift Up!Gift Up!
Not scoredMonth to monthThe terms set no early termination fee$0/mo
GiftFlyGiftFly
Not scoredMonth to monthThe terms set no early termination fee$0/mo
Givex (Shift4 Gift & Loyalty)Shift4
Not enough data12 monthsNo early termination fee clause, but you can only end the agreement at the end of each one-year term with 30 days' written notice. The exit file costs $1,000 plus 10% of the value of the gift cards issued, and the transition is at your expense.Quote only
Shift4 POS Loyalty & MarketingShift4
Not enough data36 months$100 to $750 per device for each month left, depending on your card volumeQuote only