Skip to content

Payroll software review

SurePayroll

Online payroll from a Paychex company: $29 a month plus $7 per worker, unlimited payroll runs, and year-end forms and multi-state payroll billed apart.

By SurePayrollParent company: Paychex, Inc.

RTC SCORE

6.3

#9 of 22 with enough data

Save what you pay for payroll, free

Create your free account, write down what you pay today for payroll and your other services, and see your total spend and which options could cost you less with your numbers.

Create my free account

Nobody calls or messages you unless you ask.

Our verdict

A low published price for small teams that don't need a POS link, with clear add-on fees. Count the year-end form fees in your yearly cost and check the minimum wage make-up for tipped staff.

What we like

  • Published price: $29 a month plus $7 per worker, with unlimited payroll runs and no setup fee listed.
  • Files federal, state and local payroll taxes, and its agreement says it pays penalties caused by its own breach.
  • No minimum term and no early termination fee.
  • Pays W-2 employees and 1099 contractors and handles cash tips.

What to watch

  • Year-end forms cost $50 plus $5 per form, and local taxes and extra states cost more.
  • Phone support only Monday to Friday.
  • No POS integration, and the tip credit is only mentioned in marketing.
  • Included direct deposit takes two days.

How the score breaks down

RTC Score6.3out of 10

Methodology v1.1.0

Data completeness89%

We could verify 89% of the scoring data

Strongest points
12-month payroll cost (reference restaurant), Who files payroll taxes, Published pricing
Weakest point
POS integrations

Score by criterion

  • 12-month payroll cost (reference restaurant)Weight 19%Strongest8.9 out of 10

    $1,789 over 12 months

  • Who files payroll taxesWeight 7%Strongest10.0 out of 10
  • POS integrationsWeight 6%Weakest0.0 out of 10
  • Published pricingWeight 5%Strongest10.0 out of 10
  • Tip credit and minimum wage make-upWeight 5%3.0 out of 10
  • Tips imported from POS systemsWeight 5%0.0 out of 10
  • 2026 W-2 ready for No Tax on TipsWeight 5%0.0 out of 10
  • Initial termWeight 5%10.0 out of 10
  • Live support hours a weekWeight 5%3.3 out of 10
  • Payroll in all 50 statesWeight 4%10.0 out of 10
  • Time trackingWeight 4%4.0 out of 10
  • FICA tip credit (Form 8846)Weight 3%5.0 out of 10
  • Tip pooling and tip-outsWeight 3%No data
  • Early termination feeWeight 3%10.0 out of 10
  • Unlimited pay runsWeight 3%10.0 out of 10
  • Fastest direct deposit includedWeight 3%6.0 out of 10
  • Tax penalty guaranteeWeight 3%10.0 out of 10
  • Year-end W-2 and 1099 formsWeight 2%5.0 out of 10
  • Accounting integrationsWeight 2%No data
  • Notice to avoid renewalWeight 2%10.0 out of 10
  • Garnishments and new-hire reportingWeight 2%No data
  • Declared cash tipsWeight 2%10.0 out of 10
  • State and local minimum wages built inWeight 2%No data
  • Dedicated specialistWeight 2%No data
  • Paying 1099 contractorsWeight 1%10.0 out of 10
  • Early pay for employeesWeight 1%No data

All the data, with sources

Each value links to its source. "Not published" means the vendor doesn't disclose it; "Unconfirmed" means we looked and couldn't confirm it. Data points we have for fewer than four vendors are left out until we can compare them.

Pricing
Data pointValue
Base fee$29/moSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)The price calculator uses $29; the page also shows a block starting at $39 (the household plan, with one employee, starts at $39 too).
Per employee$7Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Who counts as an employeeUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)SurePayroll charges per worker a month, without saying whether a worker not paid that month counts.
Per contractor (1099)$7Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)SurePayroll prices per worker and pays both W-2 employees and 1099 contractors.
Published pricingPublishedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Setup fee$0 one-timeSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)No setup fee is listed.
Year-end forms fee$50/yrSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Each extra state$9.99Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)A flat monthly charge for multi-state payroll.
Other feesLocal taxes carry a separate fee in areas that require them (amount not published). Accounting software integration is $4.99 a month and time clock integration starts at $5 a month plus $3 per employee.Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Taxes and forms
Data pointValue
Who files payroll taxesThe provider calculates, files and pays federal, state and local payroll taxesSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Local taxes carry a separate fee.
Payroll in all 50 statesYesSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)The price calculator lists all 50 states.
Year-end W-2 and 1099 formsPrepared and filed for an extra chargeSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Paying 1099 contractorsIncluded in payroll plansSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Tax penalty guaranteePays penalties caused by its own errorsSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)From the payroll service agreement SurePayroll publishes on its enrollment site (Rev. 3/13); the version you accept at sign-up may be newer.
Garnishments and new-hire reportingUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)New-hire reporting is included; SurePayroll doesn't say how it handles garnishments.
Paying your team
Data pointValue
Pay schedulesUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Unlimited pay runsYesSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Fastest direct deposit includedTwo business daysSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Early pay for employees (earned wage access)UnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Tips
Data pointValue
Imports tips from these POS systemsSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)SurePayroll documents time clock integrations for hours, not a POS connection for tips.
Tip pooling and tip-outsUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Tip credit and minimum wage make-upClaimed, without documented mechanicsSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)It mentions minimum wage alerts, without documenting how the make-up works.
FICA tip credit (Form 8846)Gives you a report for itSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)It says it supports FICA tip credits, without detail; its restaurant guide (July 15, 2026) sends Form 8846 to your tax adviser.
Declared cash tipsYesSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
2026 W-2 for No Tax on Tips (code TP and tipped occupation code)Not confirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Its No Tax on Tips article (Nov 20, 2025) doesn't commit the product.
2026 W-2 for qualified overtime (code TT)Not confirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)The same article covers overtime without saying how SurePayroll's 2026 W-2 reports it.
Service charges paid as wagesUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
State and local minimum wages built inUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)It mentions minimum wage alerts, without saying whether state and local minimums are built in.
Integrations and time tracking
Data pointValue
POS integrations (hours or sales data)Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)No POS integration is documented.
Time trackingOnly through an integrationSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)A paid integration with time clock software.
SchedulingUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Accounting integrationsUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Accounting software integration costs $4.99 a month; the pricing page doesn't name the programs.
Payroll engineThe vendor itselfSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)SurePayroll runs its own payroll; it belongs to Paychex.
Benefits and insurance
Data pointValue
Health benefitsThrough a partner brokerSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Workers' compensationThrough a partnerSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not available in North Dakota, Ohio, Washington or Wyoming.
Contract and exit
Data pointValue
Initial termMonth to monthSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)No minimum term; billed monthly.
Automatic renewalMonth to monthSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)No renewal term.
Notice to avoid renewal30 daysSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)From the payroll service agreement SurePayroll publishes on its enrollment site (Rev. 3/13); the version you accept at sign-up may be newer.
Early termination feeNoneSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)From the payroll service agreement SurePayroll publishes on its enrollment site (Rev. 3/13); the version you accept at sign-up may be newer.
Early termination clauseNo early termination fee. The service agreement asks for 30 days' prior written notice; you can also cancel the subscription in your account.Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)From the payroll service agreement SurePayroll publishes on its enrollment site (Rev. 3/13); the version you accept at sign-up may be newer.
Right to raise pricesSurePayroll can change its terms and fees at any time. It tries, without being obliged, to give 30 days' notice of material changes; if you don't accept, you can end the service before the change takes effect.Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)From the payroll service agreement SurePayroll publishes on its enrollment site (Rev. 3/13); the version you accept at sign-up may be newer.
Your records when you leaveUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)The agreement doesn't say what access you keep after you leave.
Support
Data pointValue
Support 24/7NoSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)
Live support hours a week55Source: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Phone support Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. Central time; help articles are available at any hour.
Dedicated specialistUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Language
Data pointValue
Employee app in SpanishUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)SurePayroll doesn't say whether its employee app works in Spanish.
Owner's dashboard in SpanishUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Pay stubs in SpanishUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)Not documented: SurePayroll's pricing, restaurant and tax pages don't mention it (checked October 1, 2026).
Support in SpanishUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)The contact page doesn't publish a Spanish line.
Contract or terms in SpanishUnconfirmedSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)We only found the agreement in English.
Website in Spanish for the USNoSource: SurePayroll (opens in a new tab)No Spanish version or language selector on the site.